Sunday, November 10, 2019
Attitudinal Behaviour Essay
Purpose Ã¢â¬â In order to classify individuals based on their needs, this paper aims to consider both self-stated attitudes and behaviours in a comprehensive range of daily Ã¯ ¬ nancial affairs. Furthermore, it aims to study the impacts of socio-demographic variables such as gender, age, and education. Design/methodology/approach Ã¢â¬â A questionnaire was answered by 1,282 respondents in the German-speaking part of Switzerland. Factor analysis revealed Ã¯ ¬ ve components. Based on these components a two-step cluster analysis (Ward and K-means analyses) identiÃ¯ ¬ ed distinct subgroups. Linear regressions were used to investigate the impacts of socio-demographic variables. Findings Ã¢â¬â Factor analysis revealed Ã¯ ¬ ve underlying dimensions of Ã¯ ¬ nancial attitudes and behaviour: anxiety, interests in Ã¯ ¬ nancial issues, decision styles, need for precautionary savings, and spending tendency. Cluster analysis segmented the respondents into Ã¯ ¬ ve subgroups based on these dimensions with an ascending order of speciÃ¯ ¬ c needs for Ã¯ ¬ nancial products. Gender, age, and education were found to have signiÃ¯ ¬ cant impacts. Research limitations/implications Ã¢â¬â Real consumption behaviour cannot be observed through the survey, which limits the external validity of the study. Practical implications Ã¢â¬â The segmentation identiÃ¯ ¬ es different levels of Ã¯ ¬ nancial competence and needs for Ã¯ ¬ nancial products. It allows Ã¯ ¬ nancial service providers to offer more effective advice and to meet customers on their own level to improve personal Ã¯ ¬ nancial management. Originality/value Ã¢â¬â Attitudes and behaviours in daily Ã¯ ¬ nancial affairs are examined to reveal individualsÃ¢â¬â¢ Ã¯ ¬ nancial competence and consequential product needs. A heterogeneous sample covers a variety of demographic groups. Keywords Personal Ã¯ ¬ nance, Savings, Questionnaires, Factor analysis, Cluster analysis, Switzerland Paper type Research paper Introduction Everyone has to manage his or her personal Ã¯ ¬ nance in one way or another. Some tend to save a lot, some like to collect information before each purchase, some like to follow their gut feelings. Private investors are not a homogeneous group but rather The authors would like to acknowledge the support of the University Research Priority Program Ã¢â¬Å"Finance and Financial MarketsÃ¢â¬ of the University of Zurich and the National Centre of Competence in Research Ã¢â¬Å"Financial Valuation and Risk ManagementÃ¢â¬ (NCCR FINRISK), Project 3, Ã¢â¬Å"Evolution and Foundations of Financial MarketsÃ¢â¬ . In addition, they would like to thank the Swiss Ã¯ ¬ nancial company that provided them with client data and the anonymous referee for the helpful comments. International Journal of Bank Marketing Vol. 27 No. 2, 2009 pp. 108-128 q Emerald Group Publishing Limited 0265-2323 DOI 10.1108/02652320910935607 individuals with various Ã¯ ¬ nancial practices combined with different levels of experience, anxiety and interest in Ã¯ ¬ nancial matters (Gunnarsson and Wahlund, 1997). In an increasingly competitive marketplace, Ã¯ ¬ nancial institutions need to emphasise customer relationships and the retention of existing customers that require an in-depth understanding of their attitudes and behaviours (Harrison and Ansell, 2002). The heterogeneous market is divided into smaller more homogeneous groups to meet speciÃ¯ ¬ c needs with a corresponding business model (Jenkins and McDonald, 1997). Market segmentation relies, in the Ã¯ ¬ nancial industry, largely on socio-demographic information to deÃ¯ ¬ ne segments for speciÃ¯ ¬ c services (Harrison, 2000). It is questionable Ã ¨ as to how appropriate they are (Jorg, 2005), therefore in this study, selected aspects of Ã¯ ¬ nancial affairs such as routines and attitudes are gathered to gain insights towards signiÃ¯ ¬ cant behavioural patt erns. The objective in this research is to examine the extent to which a broad range of private investors can be classiÃ¯ ¬ ed into a small number of clusters in order to learn about group-speciÃ¯ ¬ c needs in Ã¯ ¬ nancial affairs. More than 1,200 participants in Switzerland have answered our questionnaire with a response rate of 79 per cent. Unlike some other studies in this Ã¯ ¬ eld (e.g. Lim and Teo, 1997; Wood and Zaichkowsky, 2004), this survey is not limited to students, but includes a broader range of the public. Instead of focusing solely on savings behaviour (EBRI, 2002; MacFarland et al., 2003), the present study embraces a wider scope of daily Ã¯ ¬ nancial concerns. Thereby factor analysis exposes Ã¯ ¬ ve underlying dimensions: anxiety, interests in Ã¯ ¬ nancial issues, decision styles, need for precautionary savings, and spending tendency. We demonstrate that our respondents can, based on these dimensions, be classiÃ¯ ¬ ed into Ã¯ ¬ ve distinct groups by cluster analysis where from cluster I to V, the need for action for a better handling of Ã¯ ¬ nancial matters increases: for example, the Ã¢â¬Å"Gut-feeling followersÃ¢â¬ show a intuitive way of decision taking, disinterest in Ã¯ ¬ nancial subjects and a lack of awareness for the need of provision which make it difÃ¯ ¬ cult to argue for or to initiate remedial action. Each cluster raises key issues in meeting their needs and allows for guidance to design and adapt instruments to assist in speciÃ¯ ¬ c Ã¯ ¬ nancial requirements. To illustrate how Ã¯ ¬ nancial behaviour can be modiÃ¯ ¬ ed to improve personal Ã¯ ¬ nance speciÃ¯ ¬ cally for each group, examples from the area of retirement savings, an important part of daily Ã¯ ¬ nancial management, are chosen (Clark-Murphy and Soutar, 2005). Linear regression further reveals that the clusters highlight socio-demographic characteristics and help generate a better understanding, although one socio-demographic factor alone does not offer enough information to detect cluster membership. The main theoretical contribution of this paper is that we segment the investors based on the revealed dimensions in attitudes (e.g., level of anxiety), together with the self-stated Ã¯ ¬ nance-related behavioural pattern (e.g., spending tendency). In this way we could identify the speciÃ¯ ¬ c needs and provide different services to each subgroup. Theoretical background and literature review Individuals show considerable deviation from the expectation of rational behaviour implied by Ã¯ ¬ nancial models (Barberis, 2003). Being conscious of the empirical limitations of the homo economicus model for exploring the behaviour of private individuals, behavioural Ã¯ ¬ nance broadens the view by combining knowledge from psychology and economics ( Camerer and Loewenstein, 2004). Our study belongs to this area. However, instead of focusing on particular anomalies and biases that individuals succumb to, such as overconÃ¯ ¬ dence and procrastination (Biais et al., 2005; OÃ¢â¬â¢Donoghue and Rabin, 1998), we broaden the scope under review by studying general patterns when dealing with Ã¯ ¬ nancial issues. Market segmentation In the Ã¯ ¬ nancial services industry, market segmentation is a common method to understand better and serve the diverse customer base with its wide-ranging needs and various behaviours (Speed and Smith, 1992). Competitive pressures from deregulation of the Ã¯ ¬ nancial services market increase the requirement for market orientation and a more intimate knowledge of the market and its segments (Gunnarsson and Wahlund, 1997). Previous research has shown that there are various beneÃ¯ ¬ ts from taking a segmented approach to the marketplace: a better serving of customer requirements; a tailoring of offerings; and higher customer satisfaction (Harrison and Ansell, 2002). It can increase customer retention and create loyalty and long-term relationships that positively affect performance (Martenson, 2008). Market segmentation aims to recognise patterns of Ã¯ ¬ nancial behaviour, identiÃ¯ ¬ ed by studied segment predictors to group individuals into segments according to their product needs (Harrison, 2000). Yet, marketing in the Ã¯ ¬ nancial services industry today is still predominantly based on socio-demographic features like gender and age which are easy to identify and easy to apply in the composition of groups (Machauer and Morgner, 2001). A prediction of needs from socio-demographic characteristics cannot be assumed; therefore these widely used a priori segmentations are under review (Speed and Smith, 1992). In contrast, post hoc methods entail the grouping of respondents according to their responses to particular variables, focusing on customer motivations (i.e. needs/behaviour) that are more likely to result in a service based on individual n eed (Durkin, 2005). In research, behavioural segmentation is increasingly found (Elliott and Glynn, 1998; Soper, 2002), although researchers continue to concentrate on the Ã¯ ¬ nancial behaviour of speciÃ¯ ¬ c groups and selective variables Ã ¨ (Warneryd, 2001). This study focuses on the general population, giving a more holistic view of personal Ã¯ ¬ nancial management activities and taking attitudes and behaviour into account. Individual investors The literature on individual economic behaviour often focuses narrowly on speciÃ¯ ¬ c Ã ¨ areas such as risk attitudes (Warneryd, 1999; Wood and Zaichkowsky, 2004) or saving (Normann and Langer, 2002; Thaler and Benartzi, 2004). Other Ã¯ ¬ elds of research target investment in securities (Barber and Odean, 2001; Brennan, 1995; Keller and Siegrist, 2006) or focus on speciÃ¯ ¬ c segments such as occupational groups (e.g., dentists and Ã ¨ managers (Jorg, 2005)). SpeciÃ¯ ¬ c Ã¯ ¬ nancial issues or situations, however, are not indicative of an individualÃ¢â¬â¢s behavioural and attitudinal disposition toward Ã¯ ¬ nance. Rather an interest in Ã¯ ¬ nances or having certain habits related to managing oneÃ¢â¬â¢s Ã¯ ¬ nancial means may indeed be a moderating factor to learn about behaviours and needs (Loix et al., 2005). The attitudes and behaviours toward Ã¯ ¬ nances regarded in this study focus on individual Ã¯ ¬ nancial management behaviour. It is a topic with important implications that has not been sufÃ¯ ¬ ciently examined in Ã¯ ¬ nancial and economic behavioural studies (Loix et al., 2005). The subject is not covered by the extensive research on individualÃ¢â¬â¢s attitudes and habits towards money, as such studies focus on the meaning of money (Lim and Teo, 1997) or basic values concerning money in general as an abstract concept (Raich, 2008), and not on an individualsÃ¢â¬â¢ ways of dealing with his or her personal Ã¯ ¬ nance. Previous studies of private investors have used mainly behaviour-based criteria or attitudes and do not combine both aspects (Keller and Siegrist, 2006) that are the focus of this study. This study is not product-linked but wider ranging in that it examines the self-stated Ã¯ ¬ nancial attitudes and behaviour of individual investors. Attitudes and behaviours A frequently discussed question in research is to what extent attitudes predict behaviour. A direct relationship between attitudes and behaviour has often been found to be weak, but difÃ¯ ¬ culties in Ã¯ ¬ nding a strong relationship might derive from Ã ¨ differences in deÃ¯ ¬ nition and measurement (Warneryd, 1999). The more speciÃ¯ ¬ c the attitude is the better are the chances of Ã¯ ¬ nding a substantial correlation with behaviour if behaviour is also deÃ¯ ¬ ned as a speciÃ¯ ¬ c act (Ajzen and Fishbein, 1980). Therefore, deÃ¯ ¬ ned questions or attitudes can have predictive power and a higher correlation of attitude to-wards behaviour has been conÃ¯ ¬ rmed in studies (in a comprehensive Ã ´ meta-analysis: Glasman and AlbarracÃ ±n, 2006; Tesser and Shaffer, 1990). A further question is the beneÃ¯ ¬ t of knowledge concerning behaviour. Whilst behaviour changes over time, there is a popular assertion that Ã¢â¬Å"past behaviour is the best predictor of future behaviourÃ¢â¬ (Ajzen, 1991, p. 202). It is a reÃ¯ ¬âection of these ideas that leads to attitudes and behaviour being explored in this paper. Financial needs segmentation Several typologies concerning the Ã¯ ¬ nancial affairs of private investors can be found in the previous literature, but with more speciÃ¯ ¬ c approaches: se gmentations are based on Ã¯ ¬ nancial maturity and knowledge (Harrison, 1994), provision for retirement (Gough and Sozou, 2005) or savings strategies (Gunnarsson and Wahlund, 1997). Loix et al. (2005) come closest to the focus of this study with the question of orientation towards Ã¯ ¬ nances but their goal is to develop a measurement scale for individualÃ¢â¬â¢s Ã¯ ¬ nancial management. In this study, we examine the self-stated Ã¯ ¬ nancial attitudes and behaviour through a broader basis and do not restrict ourselves only to questions concerning risk or saving. We apply the methodology of cluster analysis to identify groups of private investors in order to obtain insight into the enforcing or modifying of speciÃ¯ ¬ c behaviour. Cluster analysis has become a common tool in marketing and is a well-adopted method for market segmentation as well as the applied factor analysis apparent in this paper (Punj and Stewart, 1983). The aim of the present study is to obtain a better understanding of peopleÃ¢â¬â¢s needs in Ã¯ ¬ nancial matters to provide adequate services and products. This study, based on Ã¯ ¬ nancial service consumers, identiÃ¯ ¬ es distinct motivational clusters that were independent of the more established socio-demographic segmentation variables used in targeting and communicating by Ã¯ ¬ nancial institutions. This study demonstrates that, by segmenting respondents on the basis of a broader range of Ã¯ ¬ nancial attitudes and behaviour, a yield of clearly interpretable proÃ¯ ¬ les can be realised and is helpful to identify those people in most need of professional Ã¯ ¬ nancial advice. This research suggests that customerÃ¢â¬â¢s Ã¯ ¬ nancial proÃ¯ ¬ les may be useful in predicting their response to new products as well as persuading them to use existing services for the speciÃ¯ ¬ c beneÃ¯ ¬ ts they value. Participants and questionnaire The data come from a questionnaire that wa s completed by 1,282 respondents from various regions of the German-speaking part of Switzerland. The respondents were recruited from two sources: 53 per cent of the participants (n Ã ¼ 680) were clients seeking consulting advice from a Swiss Ã¯ ¬ nancial planning company, together with participants in courses in Ã¯ ¬ nancial training within the same Ã¯ ¬ rm (convenient sample). The second source was employed to avoid a client bias in the study. A total of 602 study subjects (47 per cent of the total study) were identiÃ¯ ¬ ed through a combination of Ã¢â¬Å"quota and snowball sampling proceduresÃ¢â¬ (Vogt, 2005) so that its composition in terms of sex, age, and other demographic characteristics came close to reÃ¯ ¬âecting the respective proportions in Switzerland. Although not every member of the population is equally likely to be selected, the sample is composed of a wide variety of backgrounds. The diversity came from such groups as participants in a study relating to Ã¯ ¬ nancial literacy, and from different sources such as a nursing home, a group of university students, a group of teachers, company employees from four Swiss companies unrelated to the Ã¯ ¬ nancial services sector, a group of self-employed people, participants in a course for the unemployed, and a group made up of parents. The questionnaire was designed in German. Participants were Ã¯ ¬ rst asked to give their self-assessment by answering 17 questions on their Ã¯ ¬ nancial behavioural practice or attitude towards Ã¯ ¬ nancial affairs. The response format is a Ã¯ ¬ ve-point-Likert-type scale with Ã¢â¬Å"absolutelyÃ¢â¬ and Ã¢â¬Å"not at allÃ¢â¬ at the two ends of the question spectrum. Subsequently, the questionnaire contains questions concerning socio-demographic variables such as age, gender, career stage, and education. The age of participants ranges from 18 to 84 years old, with 58.9 per cent between 36 and 65 years old (n Ã ¼ 755). The natural demographic balance of men and women is reÃ¯ ¬âected in the sample with 49.3 per cent men (n Ã ¼ 632) and 50.7 per cent women (n Ã ¼ 650). The proportion of people with a university degree or equivalent is 46.6 per cent (n Ã ¼ 598), whereas 33.8 per cent participants (n Ã ¼ 433) obtained an apprenticeship (up to Ã¯ ¬ ve years). There are 14.5 per cent participants (n Ã ¼ 186) who have a high school diploma as the highest educational level, whereas 5.1 per cent participants (n Ã ¼ 65) have only attended secondary school. There are 10.5 per cent (n Ã ¼ 135) participants who were studying at a university or at another institute of higher education at the time of our survey. Methodology and results Factor analysis As the Ã¯ ¬ rst step we conducted an exploratory factor analysis, a principal component analysis, in order to determine the underlying dimensions of the Ã¯ ¬ nancial attitudes and behavioural tendencies. The chosen solution with Ã¯ ¬ ve principal components was constructed using the varimax rotation technique and can explain 53.3 per cent of the total variance. Different opinions concerning what constitut es a high loading are found in the literature, e.g. 0.3 (Gardner, 2001). Here, the rotated factor loading of 0.5 was chosen as a threshold.